Log In Register

Source & Citation Info

title:“Notes on Debates by Robert Yates (Printed by Genet)”
authors:Robert Yates
date written:1787-7-5

permanent link
to this version:
last updated:Jan. 22, 2013, 8:01 a.m. UTC
retrieved:March 3, 2021, 2:50 p.m. UTC

Yates, Robert. "Notes on Debates by Robert Yates (Printed by Genet)." Supplement to Max Farrand's The Records of the Federal Convention of 1787. Ed. James H. Hutson. New Haven: Yale University Press, 1987. 146. Print.

Notes on Debates by Robert Yates (Printed by Genet) (July 5, 1787)

Met pursuant to adjournment.
The report of the committee was read.
Mr. Gorham. I call for an explanation of the principles on which it is grounded.
Mr. Gerry, the chairman, explained the principles.
Mr. Martin. The one representation is proposed as an expedient for the adoption of the other.
Mr. Wilson. The committee has exceeded their powers.
Mr. Martin proposed to take the question on the whole of the report.
Mr. Wilson. I do not chuse to take a leap in the dark. I have a right to call for a division of the question on each distinct proposition.
Mr. Madison. I restrain myself from animadverting on the report, from the respect I bear to the members of the committee. But I must confess I see nothing of concession in it.
The originating money bills is no concession on the part of the smaller states, for if seven states in the second branch should want such a bill, their interest in the first branch will prevail to bring it forward—it is nothing more than a nominal privilege.
The second branch, small in number, and well connected, will ever prevail. The power of regulating trade, imposts, treaties, &c. are more essential to the community than raising money, and no provision is made for those in the report—We are driven to an unhappy dilemma. Two thirds of the inhabitants of the union are to please the remaining one third by sacrificing their essential rights.
When we satisfy the majority of the people in securing their rights, we have nothing to fear; in any other way, every thing. The smaller states, I hope will at last see their true and real interest.—And I hope that the warmth of the gentleman from Delaware will never induce him to yield to his own suggestion of seeking for foreign aid.

Resource Metadata